

It’s impossible to imagine an average customer entering the liquor store and thinking about which expression from Heaven Hill’s Rye Mash Bill best suits her fancy. In reality, though, this approach is not reflective of the daily experience of most consumers. wheated mash bill, barrel proof, or what have you) can be used to crown categorical champions. Alternatively, comparisons of several different whiskeys of a single type (e.g. Comparisons of varying whiskeys from a single distillery can highlight which expressions from a given range best showcase that producer’s strengths.

However, usually there’s some internal logic underpinning them. I continue to love a good head-to-head, and have embraced this format (featuring whiskeys, rather than Olympians and superheroes) in several of my reviews on this site. At this point, even our most patient readers are probably scratching their heads. The outlandishness of the competitions was matched by the earnestness of the debate, with serious consideration given to each contender’s advantages and weaknesses.Ī key feature of these discussions was their inessential nature, as they often involved fictional characters matched against celebrities, with no coexistence between the two in actuality. Who would win at croquet: Usain Bolt or Batman?īack in the time before the internet, when diversions were harder to come by, I used to while away the hours with my adolescent friends by debating these nonsense matchups.
